CCTV & Security
IP vs Analog HD CCTV Cameras: Which Is Right for Your Property?
Short answer
Analog HD cameras are simple and cost-effective, and they can reuse old coax cabling. IP cameras offer higher resolution, PoE single-cable installation and more smart features. For most new installations IP is the better choice, while analog HD still suits budget upgrades of existing sites.
Differences at a glance
| Feature | Analog HD | IP |
|---|---|---|
| Picture quality | Good HD | Up to very high resolution |
| Cabling | Coax or two-core, separate power | Cat5e/Cat6, power via PoE |
| Distance | Long runs on coax | About 100 m per cable run without extenders |
| Smart features | Basic to moderate | Rich: line crossing, intrusion, people counting on some models |
| Cost | Lower | Moderate to higher |
Choosing
- Upgrading an old analog site and wanting low cost: analog HD.
- New build or you want expansion and higher resolution: IP.
- Large sites: IP with fibre links between buildings.
Related
Compare recorders in DVR vs NVR and see how to choose a system.
Common questions
Are IP cameras always better?
Not always. For a small site with existing cabling, analog HD can be the sensible option.
Do IP cameras need a computer?
No. They connect to an NVR or switch that records locally.
What is PoE?
Power over Ethernet sends power and data on the same network cable.
